lets talk american idol some more... carmen is attractive but not talented, her quivering voice is not very technical. as for reuben, he has an incredible voice but it is not uniquely distinct. you would never recognize his voice singing a song you already knew... you probably would be able to detect his voice if it was HIS song however. the top four of the competition are: Clay, Reuben, Kimberly Caudwell, and Ricky. Clay will take this competition no doubt. that's our story and we are sticking to it. kris and andy